The Economy of God – Some Thoughts

A woman I had the pleasure of meeting somewhat recently gave me a book upon my departure. She’s one of those people whose love for God shows in her face, and when she handed it to me she said, with complete conviction, that it would change my life once I understood it.

The title was The Economy of God. My first, slightly embarrassing thought was of my budget spreadsheet. I’ve spent the ladder part of this year staring at a debt snowball, and “economy” is not a word that currently fills me with spiritual warmth.

My second thought, as a pharmacist, came a few pages in, when I realized the book’s central verb is dispense. God, the author says, wants to dispense Himself into us. I’ve spent my whole career dispensing things. That tickled me, I think.

And my third thought came when I did what I should have done first and looked up the author.

The book has a history I didn’t know about. It’s by Witness Lee, and it’s one of his principal works, first published in 1968 as a compilation of messages he gave in Los Angeles. Lee was the closest co-worker of Watchman Nee, and the book is presented as building on Nee’s foundation to unveil what Lee saw as the central revelation of the Bible: that God wants to impart Himself into man for His full expression in the church.

The movement that grew from their ministry has been argued over for decades. In December 2009 the Christian Research Institute (“CRI”) devoted an issue of its journal to reassessing Lee’s teachings, under a cover that declared “We Were Wrong” about its own critical stance, but not everyone was persuaded. Calvin Beisner, formerly of CRI, still faults Lee on several points, including two forms of modalism. Evaluations by evangelical scholars since Lee’s death have been mixed, with some concluding the movement is basically orthodox and others remaining skeptical.

I had no idea.

And I want to say up front that none of this changes how I see the woman who gave it to me. She handed me something that has fed her, and that honestly is a beautiful gift to share. But it does mean I read it differently than I might have.

Lee takes his title from 1 Timothy 1:4…. I think

In the King James, the verse warns against fables and endless genealogies, “which minister questions, rather than godly edifying.” But that’s because the manuscripts the KJV translators worked from read oikodomia, building up. Most older manuscripts read oikonomia, which the ESV renders “the stewardship from God that is by faith.”

Oikonomia is a household word. Oikos, house, and nomos, law or arrangement. It’s the management of a household: how its goods are distributed, who’s responsible for what, how the whole place runs. It’s where our word “economy” comes from, which is why my mind went to my budget.

Paul uses it in a couple different ways. Sometimes it’s God’s arrangement: “a plan for the fullness of time, to unite all things in him” (Ephesians 1:10), “the plan of the mystery hidden for ages in God” (3:9). And sometimes it’s the stewardship God entrusts to us. Paul says he was “entrusted with a stewardship” (1 Corinthians 9:17). Peter tells all believers to serve “as good stewards of God’s varied grace” (1 Peter 4:10), using the related word oikonomoi. And when Jesus told the parable of the dishonest manager, the master’s demand was, “Turn in the account of your management” (Luke 16:2).

So in the Bible, God’s economy is both His great plan for the household and the part of the household He’s placed in our hands.

Lee’s definition, however, narrows that pretty substantially. For Lee, the focal point of God’s divine enterprise is to distribute, or dispense, Himself into man. God isn’t primarily handing out blessings or assignments. He’s distributing Himself as the “household goods” for His people to possess and enjoy.

And he locates the center of that work very specifically. Drawing on the idea that a person is spirit, soul, and body (1 Thessalonians 5:23), Lee teaches that God first regenerates the human spirit and then spreads outward from there into the mind, emotions, and will, and eventually the body. Using our spirit as His center, God works Himself out through us.

I’ll be candid about what that does to me. It moves me.

So much of the Christian life I’ve watched (and, frankly, lived) treats God as a manager handing out tasks. Be at church three nights a week. Volunteer for the festival. Read your workbook. I wrote recently about a Bible study where holiness seemed to be measured in hours served, and I came home feeling full and empty at the same time.

Lee is reaching for something deeper, and he isn’t inventing it. Peter says we may “become partakers of the divine nature” (2 Peter 1:4). Paul prays that “Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith,” that we “may be filled with all the fullness of God” (Ephesians 3:17, 19). “It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me” (Galatians 2:20). “Christ in you, the hope of glory” (Colossians 1:27).

The early church took this very seriously. Athanasius, writing in the fourth century, said that Christ “was made man that we might be made God.” He didn’t mean we become divine in essence. He meant we’re brought to share in God’s life. One of the researchers who reassessed Lee noted that local church theology in this respect resembles Eastern Orthodoxy, even though its teachers say they didn’t draw from it.

If my friend meant that understanding this would change my life, I think she may be right. There’s a great difference between a Christianity where God hands me a list and one where God gives me Himself.

….But I have some questions.

The first is about the word.

Lee builds his whole framework on oikonomia, but his definition (God dispensing Himself into man) is a theological interpretation layered onto the word, not its plain meaning. The word itself is about household management, and in Paul and Peter it includes our responsibility as stewards.

When the stewardship side drops out, I worry the Christian life could become entirely about inward experience and less about faithful management of what’s been entrusted to us.

Jesus’s parables about stewards are not mystical. They’re about accounts and talents and doing the work.

The second is about the Trinity.

Lee describes the Father, Son, and Spirit in terms of a single kind of flow, and one study observes that the book’s structure presents the Father as source, the Son as expression, and the Spirit as transmission, three stages of one holy movement, and flags the passage where all three Persons are identified as “the Spirit” as the most contested in the book.

Lee leans on verses like “the Lord is the Spirit” (2 Corinthians 3:17) and “the last Adam became a life-giving spirit” (1 Corinthians 15:45). Those verses are in the Bible, and they’re mysterious. But I also remember the Jordan, where the Son came up out of the water, the Spirit descended like a dove, and the Father’s voice spoke from heaven (Mark 1:10-11). Three, present at once, distinct. Language that collapses the Persons into stages of a single flow makes me cautious, even if Lee himself denied teaching modalism. I’m not ready to call it heresy. It just means I am ready to read those pages a bit more slowly.

The third is about the human person.

The spirit, soul, body framework goes back through Watchman Nee, and it’s a long-running debate. The Bible sometimes distinguishes soul and spirit (Hebrews 4:12), and sometimes uses them almost interchangeably. Mary sings, “My soul magnifies the Lord, and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior” (Luke 1:46-47), in classic Hebrew parallelism, two ways of saying one thing.

My concern is practical. If the spirit is where God lives and the soul is a lower region to be overcome, it becomes very easy to distrust the mind and the emotions altogether. As someone who loves to think, and who has spent years learning that my emotions are signals worth listening to, I’d want to be careful there.

So where does that leave me with the book overall?

I think it leaves me grateful, and attentive.

Grateful because the heart of what Lee is pointing at (that God’s plan for His household is to fill it with Himself) is one of the most beautiful things in all of God’s Word, and I needed to hear it after a year of feeling like my faith was measured in output. Attentive because a beautiful center can still carry some framework I need to test, and the arguments around this author are real arguments, held by serious people on both sides.

It also occurs to me that the book has done to me exactly what its title says. It’s put two things in my hands: something God wants to give, and a stewardship. The gift is His life dispensed into mine. The stewardship is the responsibility to read carefully, hold what’s good, and question what needs questioning.

I don’t know yet whether it will change my life the way my sister in the Lord hopes. But I’ve started looking at my own work differently. Every day I measure and dispense medicines that are meant to go into people and change them from the inside.

And I’m left wondering what it means that God would want to do something like that with Himself.

Sources:

More Posts You May Love